I’ve had my fair share of forays into home cheesemaking—the kind that involves a kitchen full of steam, a thermometer that never seems to stay in the pot, and a lot of "is it supposed to look like this?" moments. So, when the opportunity to review the Fromaggio Smart Home Cheesemaker came up, I was immediately intrigued. The idea of a single unit that could handle the finicky temperature swings and the precise timing of curd cutting felt like a massive leap forward for the hobby.

My first impression: The Fromaggio is a super interesting, niche powerhouse that produces high-quality fresh cheese. It’s a "Thermomix for cheese" that automates the most tedious parts of the process, provided you’re ready to embrace the learning curve and the enthusiast-level price tag.

As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from qualifying purchases.

• Price: $849

• Amazon: Fromaggio Smart Home Cheesemaker

• Official site: Fromaggio

Key Specs

Design Review: The All-in-One Dairy Countertop

The Fromaggio is a surprisingly compact unit given how much it does. At 10" x 10" x 12", it fits comfortably under most kitchen cabinets. It effectively replaces a stovetop pot, a specialized thermometer, and a curd-cutting knife, consolidating them into a single, sleek footprint.

The build quality feels sturdy, particularly the stainless steel heating pot. While the machine is designed to simplify your life, it’s worth noting that it still requires a bit of "hands-on" care. For instance, while many parts are dishwasher safe, the base is not, and you’ll want to be diligent about sanitizing the internal components before every batch to ensure your cultures have a clean environment to work in.

Performance: Automating the Tedium

The real magic of the Fromaggio is how it handles the "babysitting" phase of cheesemaking. It manages the precise heating and timed stirring that usually requires you to be tethered to the stove. In my experience, this is where the machine moves from being a gadget to a legitimate tool. I found that I was no longer "chained to the stove," worrying about overshooting a temperature target by two degrees and ruining a batch. Instead, I could go about my day, listening for a beep or an app notification when it was time to act. This level of automation is a massive win for physical accessibility, too; if you struggle with the repetitive, sometimes painful stirring required for long recipes, the machine’s internal arm is a lifesaver.

Maintaining exact temperatures is arguably the hardest part of manual cheesemaking, and the Fromaggio makes it feel nearly foolproof. It solves that classic stovetop struggle of providing consistent, low heat during long ripening periods. I was particularly impressed with how it handled "cheddaring"—keeping the curds at that perfect, warm temperature during the stacking process is something that usually requires a lot of makeshift insulation, but here, the machine just handles it.

In terms of connectivity, I’ve seen various comments online regarding Wi-Fi and app syncing issues. While I didn't personally experience these glitches during my testing, it’s something to keep in mind if your home network is spotty. When it works, the app is a great companion, acting like a digital sous-chef that sends "2-minute warnings" to your phone so you know exactly when to return to the kitchen. A standout feature for me is the company’s use of Over-the-Air (OTA) updates; they can push recipe corrections and software fixes directly to the machine via Wi-Fi, which means the unit actually gets "smarter" over time as they refine things like salt levels or heating times based on community feedback.

The quality of the fresh cheese is where the machine truly earns its keep. The ricotta and queso fresco I produced were noticeably creamier and more flavorful than anything I’ve pulled off a supermarket shelf—in fact, my batch of queso fresco was "demolished" by my family within forty-eight hours. It successfully takes you from zero to home cheesemaker right out of the box, making the whole process feel far less intimidating. And when the fun is over, the cleanup is surprisingly simple; most of the removable parts are dishwasher safe, which is a welcome relief after a long day of "curd herding."

The "Not-So-Automatic" Reality: What to Expect

The Fromaggio is a brilliant assistant, but it isn't a "one-button" robot. As long as you know what you’re getting into, these manual steps are just part of the craft:

1. Adding Ingredients: You still have to be the "chef." The machine will beep or alert the app when it’s time for you to manually add your rennet, cultures, or salt.

2. Draining & Curd Handling: While there is a lifting drainer basket, you’ll often need to use a spatula to manually scrape curds from the bottom or sides of the pot to ensure you don't lose any of that precious yield.

3. Pressing (For Hard Cheeses): This is the big one. The Fromaggio produces the curds, but it cannot press them into a solid wheel. You will need to purchase a separate cheese press and manually flip the cheese at specific intervals.

4. Aging (Affinage): The machine prepares the cheese for the "cave," but it isn't the cave itself. You’ll still need a dedicated space (like a wine fridge) to age your wheels for weeks or months.

5. Cleaning & Sanitization: You’ll need to disassemble the cutter, drainer, and pot for washing. More importantly, you should manually dip parts in a sanitizer (like Star San) before use, as the machine's heating cycle isn't a substitute for full sterilization.

6. Recipe Monitoring: Some users have reported needing to manually override pre-programmed settings (like salt levels or heat times) to get the perfect result, so keep an eye on the process.

Comparisons: Finding Your Level

The Budget Option: Lékué Cheese Maker (~$30)
This is a simple silicone bowl and strainer for the microwave. It’s great for making a quick batch of basic ricotta, but it offers zero automation or precision. It’s for the casual cook, not the hobbyist.

The Serious Hobbyist Setup: Brod & Taylor Proofer + Standalone Press (~$400–$600)
This is the most direct "manual" competitor. A Brod & Taylor folding proofer gives you the precise temperature control for culturing, but you still have to do all the stirring and cutting by hand in a separate pot. When paired with a high-quality standalone press, this setup is more flexible for large batches but much messier and more labor-intensive than the Fromaggio.

Verdict: A Niche Masterpiece for the "Curd Nerd"

The Fromaggio Smart Home Cheesemaker is a well-designed, specialized tool. It is exceptionally strong at automating the most repetitive parts of making fresh and simple cheeses.

Who it’s for: The passionate home cheesemaker who wants to make cheese often and loves the idea of app-controlled precision. If you’re a "curd nerd" looking to streamline your workflow, this is a fantastic investment.

Who it’s NOT for: The casual user who just wants a quick snack. The cost and the remaining manual steps (like pressing and aging) make it a serious hobbyist tool rather than a casual kitchen appliance.

Final Score: 7.8 / 10